Cancellation Shocks Fans and Creators Alike
Fans of the quirky musical comedy series Schmigadoon! were met with disappointing news on January 18, 2024, as creator Cinco Paul confirmed that the show would not be returning for a third season on Apple TV+. Despite having already written the scripts, which include 25 new songs, the series will not be moving forward, leaving fans heartbroken and wondering about the future of the show.
A Heartfelt Message from Creator Cinco Paul
The cancellation of Schmigadoon! after just two seasons was a tough blow for everyone involved, but creator Cinco Paul expressed gratitude for the opportunity the show had. “I am sad to share that Apple will not be moving forward with season 3 of Schmigadoon!,” Paul wrote in a post on X (formerly Twitter). “The season is written (including 25 new songs), but we unfortunately won’t be making it. Such is life,” he added, reflecting on the unexpected end of the beloved series.
In his heartfelt message, Paul thanked the cast, crew, and the fans for their incredible support throughout the show’s run. “It’s a miracle we even got two seasons, honestly, and I’m so grateful we did,” Paul said. “And to all the fans of the show out there — thank you with all of my heart. Your love and support has meant so much, and the fact that you connected with our show, that it brought some joy, means the world to me.”
Optimism for the Future of Schmigadoon!
Though the cancellation came as a shock, Paul remains optimistic about the future of Schmigadoon! and hinted that the show might not be gone for good. “This was tough news to get, but the optimist in me is convinced it’s not the end of Schmigadoon! And maybe it’s even a happy beginning,” he shared. With the scripts already in place, there’s still hope among fans that the show could find a new home, allowing its magical world to continue.
Aaron Tveit and Other Cast Members Reflect on the Show’s Impact
Actor Aaron Tveit, who portrayed Danny Bailey/Topher on the show, also expressed his gratitude, reposting Paul’s message on his Instagram Story. “Thank you, Cinco, #broadwayvideo, everyone at @appletv, and this brilliant cast and crew!” Tveit wrote. “And, of course, all the fans who came and visited our little town(s).”
Schmigadoon!: A Magical Journey with Broadway Flair
Schmigadoon! debuted in 2021 and became an instant hit for its unique blend of musical theater and comedy. It followed Josh Skinner (Keegan-Michael Key) and Melissa Gimble (Cecily Strong) as they embarked on a backpacking adventure and stumbled upon a magical town where everyone behaves like they’re in a Broadway musical. Season 2 saw the couple journey to a different town with a new musical vibe, keeping things fresh and exciting for fans.
Critical Acclaim and Awards Recognition
The series earned several accolades during its short run, including a 2022 Grammy nomination for the season 1 soundtrack, as well as four Emmy nominations, with Schmigadoon! winning the Outstanding Original Music and Lyrics award. The show was also nominated for multiple Emmy awards in 2023, including categories for Outstanding Production Design and Outstanding Cinematography for a Series (Half-Hour).
The Legacy of Schmigadoon!
Despite the cancellation, Schmigadoon! remains a cult favorite, with its charming characters and catchy songs leaving a lasting impact on viewers. Even though its journey ends here, the legacy of the show lives on through the support of its dedicated fans, the talented cast, and the heartfelt messages from creator Cinco Paul. As Paul mentioned, this might just be a “happy beginning” for the world of Schmigadoon!—only time will tell if this quirky town will come to life once again.